SANDY SPRINGS, Ga. — What began with peeling wallpaper inside a multimillion-dollar Sandy Springs home has turned into a legal battle over water, mold, rotting wood, and who should pay to fix it.
The home is less than five years old, but owners Johnny and Tracy Miguel say the damage has forced their family out of the house and into an Airbnb.
“The mold was spread out. Every wall was covered in mold,” homeowner Johnny Miguel told Channel 2 consumer investigator Justin Gray as he showed what used to be his daughter’s second-floor bedroom.
That bedroom has been torn down to the studs because of water damage and mold concerns.
Miguel also showed Gray rotting wood on the wall above the garage and deterioration of wood supporting a multi-story deck. Additional beams have been placed beneath portions of the deck for safety.
“It’s pretty devastating. I don’t even really like coming to visit it, honestly, if I don’t have to,” Miguel said.
There is no dispute between the homeowners and builder Loudermilk Homes, LLC that water got into the house.
The question in this more than $4 million home is how.
Homeowners’ engineer points to exterior walls
The Miguels hired Lauren Wayne, a structural engineer with more than three decades of experience, who says the problem is with the home’s exterior wall system.
“This case is a problem with the entire exterior facade,” Lauren Wayne told Channel 2 Action News.
She says she found problems with the installation of stucco, siding, and the water-resistant barriers behind the exterior materials.
“It’s the improper installation of these materials,” she said.
A representative of the siding manufacturer also documented alleged installation problems after inspecting the property, according to documents reviewed by Channel 2 Action News.
“Some of it is just blatant that it was done incorrectly, and it’s frustrating,” Lauren Wayne said.
Those conclusions are disputed by the builder.
Builder says roof damage is likely source
Sherwin Loudermilk, founder and president of Loudermilk Homes, agreed to sit down with Channel 2 Action News and said he believes water instead entered through punctures in the home’s flat roof.
“100% water got into that house through the roof, 100%,” Loudermilk said.
He provided Channel 2 Action News photographs that he says show punctures in the TPO roofing material. His written response says a building-envelope specialist who inspected the home in February observed small punctures in the roof above the bedroom where water damage was discovered and believed the roof was the most likely source.
The same written account acknowledges that the specialist also said water could have come through the side of the house.
“If it is their fault and they had kids up on the roof or they were, you know, tromping up on a roof and they created some damage and water got into their house, that should be their responsibility,” Loudermilk said.
Loudermilk told the Miguels by email he would fix the damage if it was determined to be a construction problem.
“We’re not perfect. And the question is, the real issue is, how do you resolve those issues? And I feel like we resolve those better than anybody, any other builder that I know,” he said.
Insurance adjuster disagreed with roof explanation
At Loudermilk’s suggestion, the Miguels filed a homeowners insurance claim.
If the problem is with the roof, it would be an insurance issue, not builder responsibility.
But the insurance company denied the claim.
An insurance adjuster inspected the property in February and did not agree that water entering through the roof was the cause. According to an April 7 legal notice sent by the Miguels’ attorney, their insurance adjuster inspected the damage Feb. 19, disagreed with the builder’s roof theory and pointed instead to the area where the stucco and wood siding meet.
“There’s no signs in the ceilings that there’s moisture coming in. It’s all coming from the wall,” Lauren Wayne said.
A central point of disagreement is whether each side was given an adequate opportunity to investigate the property before significant portions of the exterior were removed.
Sherwin Loudermilk says he repeatedly proposed removing sections of siding and stucco while engineers representing both sides were present so they could determine where water was entering the house.
MORE CHANNEL 2 ACTION NEWS INVESTIGATES STORIES:
- When pets are lost or die at Georgia kennels, their histories can be hard to find
- Amazon, Microsoft and Google pledge more transparency on data center after NDA concerns
- BioLab fire exposed chemical risks. Now some federal safety rules could be rolled back
- GLP-1 drugs will now have warning label about potential increased risk of blindness
“I made that over and over and over and over again to them, and the answer was just no, no, no, and I still to this day don’t understand why,” Loudermilk said.
His written account says he offered to pay for repairs if the investigation established that defective construction was responsible. If roof damage proved to be the source, he says that expense would instead be the homeowners’ responsibility.
Documents reviewed by Channel 2 Action News show the homeowners had also tried in the spring to arrange for the parties and their experts to inspect the damage together. Those efforts went back and forth for weeks without producing a joint inspection, with each side now blaming the other for why it didn’t happen.
On July 10, an attorney representing the Miguels asked whether Loudermilk Homes wanted to conduct an inspection.
The attorney followed up on July 15 about whether the builder intended to send an engineer.
On July 20, the attorney told Loudermilk Homes’ lawyer that additional destructive testing would take place July 27.
“You and your client and any engineer are invited to attend and inspect,” the email said.
A July 28 email from the homeowners’ attorney says no one representing the builder attended.
“The engineer was back at the house yesterday, and no one from Loudermilk showed up,” attorney David Merbaum wrote.
Sherwin Loudermilk counters that significant demolition had already occurred by then, making it impossible for his representatives to determine the original source of the water.
“This is after everything’s been demoed out. This is all the evidence has been removed,” he said.
That disputed sequence of inspections and demolition has become a central issue between the two sides.
Homeowners sent formal construction-defect notice in April
On April 7, the homeowners sent Loudermilk Homes a formal notice under Georgia’s Right to Repair Act outlining the alleged construction defects.
The law establishes a process intended to give contractors an opportunity to inspect and potentially resolve alleged construction defects before litigation. The Georgia Attorney General’s Consumer Protection Division says homeowners generally must provide written notice at least 90 days before initiating a lawsuit. A contractor generally has 30 days to respond and may inspect the property, offer repairs or payment, or reject the claim.
The notice process itself does not determine whether a construction defect exists or which side is responsible.
Dispute moves toward arbitration
The fight is now moving through the dispute-resolution process required by the construction contract.
That contract contains a provision requiring disputes arising from the agreement to be resolved through binding arbitration.
On July 31, the Miguels submitted a demand for arbitration.
For the Miguels, the dispute has already meant months living outside their home.
“You’re just left here holding the bag trying to figure it out,” Johnny Miguel said.
How can buyers protect themselves while building a home?
Homebuyers are not engineers or contractors, and Lauren Wayne told Channel 2 Action News they should not be expected to identify every technical problem during construction.
But she recommends that people building custom homes consider hiring an independent owner’s representative who works for the homeowner rather than the builder and can monitor construction as it progresses.
In fact, in the Miguels construction contract with Loudermilk. the homeowners have the “right and responsibility” to inspect, examine, and test the house at reasonable times during construction, and it lays out requirements for private inspectors.
©2026 Cox Media Group





