WSBTV.comHealth
E-Mail News Alerts
Get breaking news and daily headlines.
Browse all e-mail newsletters
Related To Story
Andrew Olney/ Getty Images

Is Alcohol Actually Healthy?

Can You Pour Health Benefits Into A Mug?

UPDATED: 10:34 am EDT May 18, 2007

Prost! Slainte! Salud! No matter what the language, people have raised their glasses and toasted each other's good health for centuries.


Selecting A Bottle Of Bubbly | Find A "Skinny" Drink


Whether history's toasts were wishful thinking or a subconscious belief that the contents of those vessels truly benefited well-being, we probably will ever know. But a growing stack of modern evidence is proving that alcohol actually does offer numerous health benefits.

A Drink A Day?

Despite the data, most medical professionals stop short of prescribing moderate drinking -- defined as no more than two drinks a day for men or one a day for women -- as a way to keep the doctor away.

Dr. W. Gifford-Jones is the nom de plum for Dr. Ken Walker, a practicing physician and medical journalist in Toronto. For decades he has touted the benefits of enjoying a drink or two a day. He also has lifted more than one eyebrow by prescribing a cocktail to his post-op patients their second day after surgery -- if they are moderate drinkers.

"I think of all the medicines we give people these days -- moderate drinking is a hell of a lot safer," he said. "If you look at the side effects of drugs -- from aspirin to stronger drugs -- the list is as long as your arm. Not so with moderate intake of alcohol.

"I think alcohol is a good drug. Compared to prescription drugs? Yes, any day."

Gifford-Jones said the fear of patients potentially misusing alcohol keeps many doctors from promoting alcohol's health benefits.

"What happens, when you go to a medical convention, and you begin debating the pros and cons (of moderate alcohol consumption): The ones against it are against it. But the ones for it say, 'We can't say that we are for drinking because of those that will drink too much.' And I say, 'If that's the case, why don't we take cars off the road because some will drive 140 mph?'"

Alcohol Is Alcohol -- Or Is It?

Evidence is mounting that the moderate drinker might get a health boost from imbibing. But are all alcoholic drinks created equal?

Yes and no, according to Gifford-Jones.

"There's a lot of talk about red wine. French red-wine makers would love it if we only touted red wine's health benefits. But I don't think it makes any difference, really. I think it's the alcohol (that provides the health benefits)," Gifford-Jones said.

More than two decades' worth of studies have credited daily moderate alcohol consumption with preventing heart attacks and strokes, helping to regulate insulin, staving off age-related dementia and even preventing osteoporosis and certain cancers. Other studies have suggested that adults who enjoy a drink or two daily have fewer incidents of emergency-room visits, fewer gallstones and intestinal disorders and even fewer bouts with the common cold.

But, most recently, one adult beverage has been touted as offering additional health benefits. Surprise! It's not wine.

Beer's Bounty

Research by Dr. Margo A. Denke, an associate professor of medicine at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical School, suggests that beer might be a healthier quaff than red wine.

Denke determined that beer contains healthy doses of polyphenols that are similar to amounts in red wine. Polyphenols are antioxidants credited for raising good cholesterol and staving off certain cancers. The research also determined that beer has as much as five times the polyphenols as white wine.

Additionally, researchers at Oregon State University recently discovered that hops, one of the main ingredients in beer, contain isoflavinoids -- plant-based estrogens that have been found to inhibit prostate, breast and colon cancer.

Because beer is made from grain, it contains protein. Craft beer, the artisan beer made in small batches by independent brewers, typically is not filtered, so it is chock-full of vitamins and minerals from the yeast still suspended in the liquid.

"Beer is 93 percent water, no fat, no cholesterol, no triglycerides, no sugar," Gifford-Jones said. "(Beer has) significant amounts of magnesium and potassium and other minerals as well as vitamins B2, B6 and folic acid … it's a damn good beverage."

And a darn fine reason to raise a toast with a glass of beer. To your health, of course.

Check WSBTV.com all week for these great diet-related features:

  • Monday -- Weight-Loss Gadgets Go High Tech
  • Tuesday -- Can You Find A Healthy French Fry?
  • Wednesday -- Are Salads Sabotaging Your Diet?
  • Thursday -- Do Coffee Drinks Fit Into Your Diet?
  • Friday -- Which Cocktails Fit Into Your Diet?
  • More Extras:


    Market Place

    Sponsor Links

    Links We Like

    Floods can have a devastating effect on your life. Find out what you should do to keep yourself and your family safe in the aftermath. More Details

    Back to (eating) basics! Here’s a refresher on the food pyramid and food basics, as well as a nutrition routine that will work for you. More Details

    You’re feeling confident and you really want this job. Don’t shrink your chances of landing it by making any of these six common interview mistakes. More Details

    Like online video? Then you'll love Now See This.

    Links We Like includes a selection of information, tools and resources from our partners and sponsors.

    Health Topics & Information

    Sun-induced wrinkles are bad enough. Skin cancer is potentially fatal. Let us show you how to enjoy the sun without risking your health. More Details

    Revolution Health

    Caregiving

    How Alzheimer's is Treated
    Caring.com
    This guide to Alzheimer's treatment will help you understand the path forward following an Alzheimer's diagnosis. More Details



    Caring.com

    Diet & Fitness Tools

    Even if you feel loyal to the trainer you've been working with, there may come a time when you're ready to move on. Learn how to bow out of your fitness relationship gracefully.  More Details

    SparkPeople

    Today In My Life

    Smoothies seem like they'd be a safe bet for any diet. Find out if they could sabotage your health and diet. More Details


    Does pet insurance sound like a ridiculous expense? Find out why pet insurance could save you a bundle and save your pet at the same time. More Details


    exercise trends
    Does the thought of working out make you feel ill? Find out if working out is worth your time. More Details


    Back To Top